Beneath the Paint: The Rediscovery of Robert S. Duncanson


The first thing Michael J. Ruzga remembers uncovering was a peach.
Then came an onion, a purple turnip and eventually a cluster of purple grapes hanging over the edge of a bowl. For five months, the paintings conservator had been removing layers of paint, plaster and grime covering two still-life murals by Robert S. Duncanson in the foyer of Cincinnati's Taft Museum of Art. Some layers dissolved. Others came away in pieces. One, Ruzga told those gathered for the November 10 unveiling, became what conservators scientifically call sludge.
The grapes were a particularly interesting discovery. Nicholas Longworth, who commissioned Duncanson to paint the foyer between 1850 and 1852, had made much of his fortune in winemaking. Ruzga said these might be the first grapes identified in the murals, possibly included as a reference to the man who paid for them. Removing earlier restoration materials revealed another cluster hanging over the edge of a bowl.
Longworth was among the wealthiest men in the country when he commissioned Duncanson to decorate the foyer of his Cincinnati home, then known as Belmont. The young artist painted eight monumental landscapes, each approximately nine feet tall, along with smaller still-lifes above the doorways.
The Taft considers them the most significant surviving pre-Civil War domestic murals in the United States, although the paintings spent much of their history hidden from view.
Wallpaper covered the walls sometime in the nineteenth century. When the house became the Taft Museum of Art in 1932, removing it revealed the landscapes, but two of the still-lifes remained damaged and incomplete. The museum's first director had them covered with wall paint and commissioned a recreation above the Music Room doorway. Visitors spent the next 90 years walking beneath that replacement, unaware that Duncanson's originals remained concealed on either side.
Following preliminary testing in 2024, conservation began in June 2026. Ruzga, who had previously served as the Taft's chief conservator, worked through seven layers totaling approximately 20,000 square inches of material when their areas were added together. Beneath the grime were coats of green-blue paint, plaster, ochre and olive-green paint. Some required cleaning solutions, others mechanical removal. Near Duncanson's original paint, he slowed to careful work with swabs and adjusted solvents. By mid-October, both paintings had been restored.

Angela Fuller, the Taft's assistant curator, researched the architectural changes made to Longworth's home and reconstructed how the foyer may have appeared in the 1850s. Her findings suggest that the restored still-lifes originally decorated two separate doorways, with a ninth monumental landscape possibly occupying the space between them. Renovations in the late nineteenth century replaced those doorways with one central opening, damaging the still-lifes and potentially destroying another mural. No surviving image or description has established whether that ninth painting existed or what it might have depicted.
Kobi Morgan, a research fellow at the Taft, has searched nineteenth-century newspapers for evidence of Duncanson's career, finding exhibition announcements and reviews dating back to his early years as an artist.
Yet Morgan has found no contemporary newspaper account documenting his work on Longworth's foyer. The murals' accepted attribution rests on scholarly examination of his style and surviving work, while Morgan continues looking for contemporary documentation of the commission.
While Fuller followed the architectural history and Morgan searched the newspapers, Cincinnati researcher Chris DeBow supplied equipment that allowed the conservation team to look beneath the paint itself. Using infrared reflectography, they examined details invisible on the finished surfaces. Researchers from the University of Cincinnati contributed scientific analysis, including X-ray fluorescence and Raman spectroscopy, to investigate the materials Duncanson used.
The infrared images revealed graphite drawings beneath the landscapes. Flowers appeared in greater detail than survives in the visible paint, buildings emerged with carefully established outlines, and trees were sketched in loose, quick marks. Researchers could even see where Duncanson had changed his mind, adjusting elements as his compositions developed.
For Fuller, who has spent years studying the foyer, seeing those drawings appear on the monitor was among the most memorable moments of the project. More than 170 years after Duncanson painted the room, researchers could examine decisions he made before covering his sketches with color.
During the unveiling, Ellen Roberts, the Taft's director of curatorial affairs, described researchers returning to nineteenth-century correspondence, legal documents and newspaper accounts to correct longstanding inaccuracies in Duncanson's biography.
Among the findings she announced was that Duncanson had been born free in upstate New York to parents who were previously enslaved in Virginia, placing his family's experience of slavery a generation closer than some earlier accounts suggested.

Duncanson learned decorative painting through his family in Michigan before arriving in Cincinnati around 1840 to pursue fine art. The city, known as the Athens of the West, offered a growing artistic community despite limited formal training opportunities. Hestudied paintings and prints, worked in portraiture and still-life, and developed the landscape painting that eventually earned him international recognition.
Some of the most revealing details about his personal life have emerged from records that had little apparent connection to art. Earlier this year, art historian Katherine Gregory and Chris DeBow, who also contributed to the mural research, published findings from two nineteenth-century lawsuits containing more than 700 pages of testimony involving Duncanson's family.
In 1858, Duncanson married Phoebe Ann Taylor, whose father, Milton Taylor, was a Kentucky enslaver. Her mother, Anna Evans, had been enslaved by Taylor, who never married her. Taylor also maintained a friendship spanning more than two decades with Levi Coffin, the Cincinnati abolitionist known for helping enslaved people escape through the Underground Railroad. Coffin arranged placements and education for Taylor's children with families in Indiana, even as their father continued enslaving people.
One lawsuit preserved Coffin's testimony about Duncanson's character, while another, involving Taylor's estate, revealed that one version of his will left Phoebe a single cent and provided $1,000 for her son, Milton Taylor Duncanson. The records also establish that Taylor helped finance Duncanson's 1865 voyage to Europe, when his paintings were exhibited in Dublin under Canadian sponsorship.
The records place Duncanson within relationships that crossed the Ohio River as regularly as the people and commerce moving between Cincinnati and Kentucky.
By then, Duncanson's work had carried him through Canada and Europe, where he developed a fascination with landscapes that he continued painting long after leaving them. Rather than complete his work outdoors, he sketched what he encountered and rearranged those observations in his studio, creating landscapes drawn from both memory and imagination.
The Ohio River, separating Cincinnati from slaveholding Kentucky, appears in one of Duncanson's local landscapes. Around 1851, he created Cincinnati from Covington, Kentucky, an unsigned painting attributed to him that draws from an 1848 engraving. He altered figures in the foreground, including replacing a white man carrying a rifle with a Black man holding a scythe. Across the river, Cincinnati's factories send smoke into the sky. Scholars have read the changes as commentary on slavery. Duncanson left no explanation of his own.

At the November 10 unveiling, poet Ajanaé Dawkins, a former Duncanson Artist-in-Residence, returned to the Taft to read a poem written for the forthcoming exhibition catalog. She spoke about the pastoral tradition and the question of who gets to write about flowers and nature, particularly when Black artists are expected to address the political circumstances surrounding them.Returning to Duncanson's paintings while writing, she had noticed something about the animals.
They were never fenced in.
The rivers, mountains, birds and other creatures inhabited landscapes without the boundaries humans had imposed on one another. Dawkins's poem, Under the Right Light, began with an epigraph from Ohio poet Hanif Abdurraqib questioning how Black people could write about flowers during times of suffering.
As she read, the poem moved through birdsong, berries, animals and open land, imagining a world where freedom belonged so naturally to creation that describing a mountain or river as free would sound absurd. She brought Duncanson into that landscape, an artist who painted imagined Edens and distant mountains in a country where freedom was anything but universal.
When she finished, Roberts admitted she was a little teary-eyed before beginning her remarks.
Dawkins is one of the artists who have participated in the Taft's Duncanson Artist-in-Residence Program, established in 1986 with poet Nikki Giovanni as its inaugural resident. Cincinnati painter Ayana Ross became the 40th resident in 2026. The museum is also preparing its first major Duncanson retrospective in more than 30 years, opening October 30, 2027. Organized with the Virginia Museum of Fine Arts, the exhibition will bring together approximately 80 paintings and historical materials, accompanied by a scholarly catalog incorporating new research into his life.
Duncanson died in 1872 at just 51, after returning to Cincinnati following his success abroad. He continued painting during his final years, despite an illness whose precise causes remain uncertain.
For more than 170 years, his paintings remained in the same house while the world around them changed. Doorways disappeared, wallpaper covered the landscapes, and generations passed beneath paintings they did not know were there. Court records survived elsewhere, preserving details of his family and relationships that would remain largely unknown for more than a century.
Art is more than something beautiful, more than the careful decisions and complicated thoughts of the person who created it. It is a window into the past, left slightly open for those of us who come after. Through it, we catch glimpses of a world we can no longer enter, of the people who lived in it and the things they chose to leave behind. We may never see the whole picture, but every detail that survives brings us a little closer.




Comments